Kyle Mathews' Blog

The problem of too-general tools

Posted in | »

There was a nugget of a comment today on the Lean Startup Circle from William Pietri:

However, having made the mistake of building too-general tools before, let me offer a bit of advice. Tools may be general, but people only have specific problems. So if you want an individual to choose to use your software, you have to solve their specific problem well. Generality is a consequence of extracting the similar bits of specific problems, not a goal on its own (however much that appeals to gadget nerds and toolbuilders like us). Real users mainly appreciate that generality later, if they ever do, when they have a second specific problem that is now easier to solve because they're familiar with your tool.

It struck me because I'm slowly starting to see this is part of the problem I'm facing with my educational tool, Eduglu. Right now I pitch Eduglu as a "social learning platform" that includes a number of learning tools out of the box and can easily be extended to meet specific needs of the learning organization that adopts it. But when I pitch, I don't seem to be moving anyone. It seems my pitch is falling into the too-general tool trap that William warned against. Yes, an adopting organization can use it for all sorts of things, eventually, but people don't buy things to solve "all sorts of things". They buy things to meet very specific needs.

Or as Sean Murphy put it in another thread, narrower focus & deeper pain is better.

The hardest part of starting a company I think is learning to understand how others think and feel about something. As a toolbuilder, I'm very used to evaluating generic tools and understanding how to apply them to solve my specific problems. But most people aren't as adept at that art. I need to understand how to get inside people's heads and intimately understand what they need and the learn to present what I'm building in a way that it will be obvious to them how my tool will solve their problems.

Submitted by Kyle Mathews on Wed, 06/02/2010 - 19:49

Second release of Eduglu

Posted in | »

New release of Eduglu

I'm pleased to announce the second release of Eduglu! Eduglu is a Drupal distribution designed to support social learning at institutions of higher learning. It's available for download now at http://eduglu.com/download-eduglu. Since the first release, We've squashed dozens of major and minor bugs and made the significant jump to the Spaces 3 and Context 3.

Eduglu helps learners connect with one another and form learning communities. Eduglu provides online spaces for groups to learn together.

Our social learning platform ships with a number of powerful social learning applications including discussion boards with full email integration (like Google Groups), polls, and wikis.

I recorded a quick screencast demoing an initial setup of Eduglu. Check it out to get a flavor for what Eduglu can do.

Hosted Eduglu coming

I'm also rather excited to announce that a fully supported hosted version of Eduglu is coming. Schools and other organizations will soon be able to easily sign-up for hosted Eduglu to meet the social learning needs of their organization. Head over to eduglu.com and leave your email address to hear when we open up for business and to provide early feedback.

This will be our initial stab at creating a sustainable business model for our Drupal educational distribution. There's been a lot of discussion lately in the Drupal community about finding business models that can help create sustainable Drupal Distributions. I'm not sure hosted Eduglu is the right business model for that task but since a startup is "an organization formed to search for a repeatable and scalable business model", we'll give this business model a try for awhile as we look for ways to freshen the stagnant world of educational technology.

What's coming next for Eduglu?

Eduglu works well with 500-1000 members. But we want it to work for much much larger organizations. Organizations the size of my alma mater Brigham Young University that has 30,000 students and 250,000+ alumni. To make Eduglu work on that scale, we'll be adding features such as group suggesting, robust search and filtering, activity streams, and twitter-style following.

Also we're working on a number of social learning applications. Right now Eduglu ships with four social learning applications. A discussion/mailing list, wiki, and polling.

The next two major applications we'd like to ship are a blogging application that let's learners blog on various things they are learning and comment on other's blogs. If the learner has an existing blog, they'll be able to connect it to their Eduglu blog so new posts there are automatically imported.

The second application is a Group RSS Reader that lets a group of learners subscribe to content via RSS and provides various means for rating, sorting, sharing, and discussing content brought into the group.

Both are powerful learning tools that help students more easily share what they are learning and track and discuss the best ideas that are being written about on the Internet and we're excited to get them out into the wild.

Submitted by Kyle Mathews on Tue, 06/01/2010 - 21:06

Conversation

Posted in | »

From British political philosopher Michael Oakeshott:

Conversation is not . . . a contest where a winner gets a prize, . . . it is an endless, unrehearsed, intellectual adventure in which in imagination we enter a variety of modes of understanding the world and ourselves. And, we are not disconcerted by the differences, or dismayed by the inconclusiveness of it all.

I really like that. Good conversation is good for the soul.

Taken from Andrew McAfee's "Enterprise 2.0" book.

Submitted by Kyle Mathews on Mon, 04/26/2010 - 20:48

Notes from "The Future of Teaching & Learning" conference -- Tools and Technology Models

Posted in | »

Two questions from moderator:

* What will the next generation of learning tools look like?
* What do Universities need to do to prepare?

Marko Turpeinen from Helsinki Institute for Information Technology demoing Sizzle.

DrChuck warning that what works for small sizes don't scale. Too much friction to using these tech tools. There should be a one-click install.

He envisions large diverse ecosystem of learning applications where teachers, grad students, small startups build learning tools that all interoperate with one another. Like the app store -- teachers can find apps and click to add them depending on their need.

For all this talk about next generation learning -- very very few people are doing anything similar. Huge inertia. Have to build pathways into future. Lower friction to using new tools. Dr. Chuck looking at adding escape hatches into major LMSs.

Submitted by Kyle Mathews on Sat, 04/17/2010 - 19:39

Notes from "The Future of Teaching & Learning" conference -- Howard Rheingold's keynote

Posted in | »

First Keynote from Howard Rheingold.

Started teaching a digital journalism class then moved on to teaching digital literacy. When first started teaching classrooms, thought about how to use online media to overcome disadvantages of teaching in classrooms namely a) not all teachers good at speaking extemporously and b) classroom learning militates against thoughtfulness, can't share thought that occurs an hour after class.

First started experimenting with using online tools for learning in 1995.

When first started teaching in 2005? Used wikis from one tool, forums from another, blogs from another. Immediate feedback from students was this was too complex. So thought about consolidating tools. Entered Haystack competition and won some money to create the socialmediaclassroom.com.

Socialmediaclassroom tool is freely downloadable or you can ask for hosted version. He's developed a number of lesson plans for introducing participatory media to students.

Developed way within Drupal to tie all work done around a lecture to be listed on page.

Says forums not used as much as 10-15 years ago.

Unique accordance of forums -- long-lasting conversations on topics. Help students get to know each other. Continue classroom discussions asynchronously online.

Introducing other features of socialmediaclassroom -- blogs w/ rich media, group chat, syllabus in the wiki, social bookmarking (which is new to a lot of students) -- use to collect resources for class project. Depending on class, sends students to delicious or diigo for discovery of different resources.

Has found that moving classroom chairs into a circle resulting in increase in classroom conversation.

Has co-teaching teams made up of students. He asks them to lists concepts and terms talked about in each class. Then other classmates fill out the descriptions.

Surprised at how illiterate most students were when he started teaching college students.

Essence of what skills needs to teach children -- How can you find the answer to any question? How do you know that what you find is accurate?

Example he uses -- if do search for "martin luther king jr" The 8th result is from martinlutherking.org -- which is a website slamming on MLK. Used whoisit.com to find martinlutherking.org owned by white nationalist site Stormfront.

Seems clear that youth are moving from passive consumption to active participation. Youth can create as well as consume online.

Gave a number of examples of how students are using social tools to help organize collective action.

We need to look at network theory, sociology research, network literacies, media theory as we redesign education for the digital age.

Don't just pay attention to technology, also pay attention to literacies.

Social medias are not always appropriate to teaching

Not add ons, essential elements of student's lives of today and tomorrow. Need to help students understand social media.

Submitted by Kyle Mathews on Sat, 04/17/2010 - 17:04

The importance of being excellent

Posted in | »

I've been sitting on this blog post for months now trying to crystallize my thoughts but having failed to do so I've decided that I'm perhaps not yet mature or experienced enough to understand my motivations. So I'll suffice with a few thoughts and a video and perhaps return to this subject at some point in the future.

The following video is from Bronco Mendenhall, the football coach at BYU, my alma mater. If you'll excuse that it's a commercial for BYU, I think you'll find it quite good. Bronco's line at the end comes pretty close to expressing why I want to be an excellent person and to do excellent work -- "Never forget that so much depends on what you do today."

For whatever reason, I've been blessed to a high degree with good parents, good health, intelligence, excellent education, and many more advantages. But I can take little credit for these. To quote BYU's President Samuelson, "We must never forget that we figuratively eat fruit grown on trees we did not plant, drink from wells we did not dig, learn and live in buildings we did not build, and are warmed by fires for which we did not provide fuel (see Deuteronomy 6:10–12)."

Most of the happiness and prosperity I enjoy are the results of good decisions and teachings of my parents and the generally good and wise decisions of world leaders which have led to the current general peace and prosperity most parts of the world enjoys (including my part of the world in the United States).

Being the recipient of so many advantages, I feel a great obligation to pay forward all that has been given to me. As my current happiness and prosperity is dependent on the decisions and work of previous generations, so too the happiness and prosperity of the current and yet unborn generations depends, to some degree, on the decisions and work I do, today.

If we desire, each of us can do a great deal of good in our time here on earth. And the first step toward that goal is a commitment to excellence.

Submitted by Kyle Mathews on Mon, 04/12/2010 - 01:03

My social learning Drupal distribution Eduglu is out for testing

Posted in | »

The first alpha of Eduglu is out and ready for testing. Download it at http://community.eduglu.org/release-announcement/node/8

What I hope to accomplish with this first Alpha?

My hope is that releasing this first of Eduglu will start a conversation about what shape should a Drupal educational distro take. Eduglu is a partial-implementation of my vision of what an Drupal education distro should be. But I'm well aware that my vision is limited in many ways and that the problems I've designed Eduglu to solve probably don't even begin to cover all the different problems you as a collective are trying to solve.

So let's get the conversation going. What do you think Eduglu should be? What problems are you facing? What would your dream social learning website be? If you're building some sort of social learning tool on Drupal already (as I know many of you are), what are you trying to do and how?

So this first alpha is a chance for us to talk about what Eduglu should be. Once we've decided what Eduglu should be, we can start pushing toward a stable Beta release, fixing bugs and adding missing features.

Let's get started!

Screencast of installation and initial setup of Eduglu

Submitted by Kyle Mathews on Mon, 03/22/2010 - 20:19

Looking for Alpha Testers for Eduglu, a new Drupal Install Profile for Higher Education

Posted in | »

I've been working on a social learning site based on Drupal for the past two years as a student at Brigham Young University and am now working towards readying it for its maiden release into the world as a full-fledged Drupal install profile.

My goal with Eduglu is to:
a) Provide a superb out-of-the-box social learning engine to help departments, clubs, classrooms, and other campus groups communicate, collaborate, and learn with one another.
b) Support a social learning platform which individual universities and Drupal shops can integrate with existing tools and services and use to build custom tools supporting specific learning practices.

Or in simpler terms, Eduglu = robust social learning engine + pluggable educational tools.

For Drupalers, Eduglu is built on the same stack of modules as Open Atrium; Organic Groups, Spaces, Context, and Features.

I'm also working to start a company to provide commercial support and hosting for Eduglu.

But we're not there yet. My plan is to make the first beta release by Drupalcon where I'll be presenting more about Eduglu. But to be ready by then, I need alpha testers. If you're interested in becoming an alpha tester, please contact me. I'll be preparing an initial release over the next couple of weeks.

Also, if you do Drupal consulting in higher education, I'd love to work with you. Please contact me and let's discuss how we can work together.

Lastly, if you're an educator working in higher ed, I'd love to talk to you as well. Especially people working at online or virtual colleges and community colleges. If there's an educational tool you've dreamed of having -- or tried building and failed -- contact me and tell me about it and I might just build it for you.

And if you're not in one of the above three groups but know someone who is -- please connect me with those people.

I'll be doing a bit of travel in a couple of weeks. I'll be in Boston February 17th-20th, New York February 22-23 and Washington DC on the 24th-25th. If you're in one of those cities and want to meet and talk Drupal/higher education, let's get in touch!

Thanks all! It's going to be an exciting ride and I'm looking forward to it.

Submitted by Kyle Mathews on Fri, 02/05/2010 - 18:47

An Education Syllogism

Posted in | »

  1. Schools exist to prepare students to thrive in the environment where they live.
  2. The environment we live in has changed significantly in the past fifty years from a mechanistic to an electronic world.
  3. Therefore, schools must change their methods for how they prepare students from mechanistic preparation (fixed length/content courses, categorized knowledge) to electronic preparation (pattern recognition, rhizomic learning).
Submitted by Kyle Mathews on Tue, 02/02/2010 - 22:24

McLuhan predicts newspaper's demise in 1965.

Posted in | »

Reading through "Understanding Media: The Extensions of Man" by Marshall McLuhan, I came across this gem of a quote:

The classified ads (and stock-market quotations) are the bedrock of the press. Should an alternative source of easy access to such diverse daily information be found, the press will fold.

And I think we all know how that's turned out.

Submitted by Kyle Mathews on Sat, 12/19/2009 - 20:29